When working at height, whether it’s for construction, maintenance or repair projects, two popular options come to mind, Mobile Elevated Work Platforms; more commonly known as MEWPs, and scaffolding. Both serve the purpose of providing access to elevated areas, but they have distinct differences in terms of functionality, cost and practicality.
Evaluating the specific requirements of your project can help determine whether the flexibility of MEWPs or the stability of scaffolding is better suited to meet your unique needs. In this blog, we’ll explore the pros and cons of MEWP rental versus scaffolding to help you make an informed decision for your next project.
Mobile Elevated Work Platforms
MEWPs, also known as mobile elevated work platforms, are versatile machines designed to lift workers and their tools to various heights. They come in different types, including scissor lifts, boom lifts and personnel lifts, each suited for specific applications. Below, we look into the pros of MEWPs.
- MEWPs can access hard-to-reach areas with ease, thanks to their mobility and adjustable platforms. They are suitable for both indoor and outdoor use, making them versatile for different types of projects.
- With quick setup and easy manoeuvrability, MEWPs allow workers to access height rapidly, increasing productivity on the job site. They are particularly beneficial for time-sensitive projects.
- MEWPs are equipped with safety features such as guardrails, harness attachment points and emergency descent systems, reducing the risk of falls and accidents compared to other elevated work methods.
- Unlike scaffolding, which may require multiple access points and climbing up and down, MEWPs provide a single access point, simplifying movement for workers and their tools.
There are of course some disadvantages of MEWPs which we look at below in more detail.
- Renting a MEWP can be more expensive than scaffolding, especially for short-term projects. Additionally, there may be additional costs for transportation, setup and operator training.
- While MEWPs offer significant reach, they may not be suitable for extremely high or intricate work areas. In such cases, specialised equipment or alternative access methods may be required.
- Certain types of MEWPs may have limitations when it comes to uneven or rough terrain, requiring additional precautions or alternative solutions.
Scaffolding
Scaffolding has been a traditional method of providing temporary structures for work at height for centuries. It involves assembling a framework of tubes and boards to create a stable platform. Let’s examine the pros and cons of using scaffolding.
- In many cases, scaffolding can be more cost-effective than renting MEWPs, especially for long-term projects or when extensive access is required.
- Scaffolding can be tailored to fit the specific dimensions and requirements of the project, providing flexibility and accessibility to various areas of the site.
- Once erected, scaffolding offers a stable platform for workers to perform tasks at height, with minimal movement or sway, enhancing safety and efficiency.
- Scaffolding can be built to reach greater heights than certain types of MEWPs, making it suitable for tall structures or complex architectural features.
However, there are some cons to scaffolding too.
- Erecting scaffolding can be time-consuming, especially for larger or more complex structures, delaying the start of work and impacting project timelines.
- Scaffolding may not always be suitable due to space restrictions. Scaffolding requires sufficient space for assembly and may not be feasible in tight or congested work areas, limiting its applicability in certain environments.
- Scaffolding needs regular inspection and maintenance to ensure structural integrity and safety compliance, adding to the overall cost and management of the project.
MEWP Rental vs Scaffolding; Which Will You Choose?
Both MEWP rental and scaffolding offer viable solutions for working at height, each with its own set of advantages and limitations. When choosing between the two, consider factors such as project duration, budget, site conditions and specific requirements. Ultimately, selecting the right access solution will contribute to the success and safety of your project.
Should you need further advice on the most suitable aerial setup for your project, why not reach out to a dedicated provider that specialises in all things aerial? If you are interested in doing just that, then look no further than Cherry Picker. Here we offer a wide range of aerial systems for hire that are sure to suit your needs, just visit our website or contact us directly to find out more. This can be done by giving us a call on 0818 228 229, by emailing us at sales@cherrypicker.ie or by filling in the relevant information into our online contact form and we will get back to you in no time with the further information you require.